Here are many of the items covering the U.S. Supreme Court’s recent decision in Trinity Lutheran holding that Missouri could not exclude the church from its playground-grant program.
SCOTUSblog
-
Symposium: The justices reach broad agreement, but on a narrow question
-
Symposium: The Constitution provides a level playing field for people of faith
-
Symposium: Playground resurfacing case provides soft landing for state “no aid” provisions
- Symposium: Trinity Lutheran and Zelman – Saved by footnote 3 or a dream come true for voucher advocates?
-
Symposium: Court ruling bolsters religious liberty… beyond the playground
-
Symposium: Bad news from Trinity Lutheran – Only two justices support the establishment clause
-
Symposium: Playground resurfacing case provides soft landing for state “no aid” provisions
Academic analysis
Ira C. Lupu & Robert W. Tuttle, Trinity Lutheran Church v. Comer: Paradigm Lost?, (Forthcoming, American Constitution Society for Law & Policy Supreme Court Review, October Term 2016)
News coverage and analysis
The New York Times: States Must Aid Some Church Programs, Justices Rule
USA Today: Supreme Court declares churches eligible for some public funds
The Washington Post: Supreme Court sides with religious institutions in a major church-state decision
Reuters: U.S. top court backs church in major religious rights case
Politico: States must support some church programs, high court rules
Fox News: Supreme Court rules for Missouri church in dispute over public funding access
Bloomberg: Church Rights Strengthened by Supreme Court Playground Case
ABA Journal: Supreme Court rules for church that wanted state grant to resurface playground
ReligiousLiberty.TV: Supreme Court: State must include church in public funding scheme
The Hill: Supreme Court rules churches are eligible for some public funds
NBC News: Supreme Court Rules States Cannot Refuse All Financial Aid to Churches
CNN: Supreme Court rules for church preschool in religious liberty case
NPR: Supreme Court Rules Religious School Can Use Taxpayer Funds For Playground
ReligionsLiberty.TV
- Supreme Court: State must include church in public funding scheme
-
States prohibiting all non-public school funding may escape Trinity Lutheran impact
Religion Clause: Supreme Court Holds Denial of Playground Resurfacing Grant To Church Violates Free Exercise Clause
ManagingYourChurch: Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Christian Schools
ECFA: Missouri Church Scores Major Supreme Court Victory
Indiana Lawyer
- Supreme Court rules for Missouri church in playground case
- Supreme Court last day notable for what was and wasn’t said
Commentary favoring the majority
Library of Law and Liberty
- “Why Trinity Lutheran is the Most Important Case of the 2016 Term” by John O McGinnis
-
Blaine’s Descendants Disinherited
-
Trinity Lutheran Church and Unconstitutional Conditions
Above the Law: Minority Of Court Would Rather Not Make A Federal Case Out Of Trinity Lutheran, A Federal Case
Law and Religion Forum: “Blaine Amendment” Case Decided, Without Reference to Blaine Amendments or Animus Inquiry
Cato Institute: Trinity Lutheran Ruling Only Gets Us Closer to Equality in Education
- [Eugene Volokh] When may the government discriminate against religious institutions?
-
[Randy Barnett] Does Trinity Lutheran mark the “end of originalism”
Wagenmaker & Oberly blog: Supreme Court Reproaches Missouri for Religious Discrimination and Protects Religious Liberty
Commentary criticizing the decision
The Atlantic
- The Supreme Court Strikes Down a Major Church-State Barrier
- A Major Church-State Ruling That Shouldn’t Have Happened: In Trinity v. Comer, there was no remaining dispute between the actual parties — and both the majority opinion and the leading dissent got the issue wrong.
Slate
- Did the court just seriously wound the separation of church and state?
- Goodbye, Establishment Clause: The Supreme Court’s ruling in Trinity Lutheran v. Comer threatens to obliterate the divide between church and state.
Vox: What a SCOTUS decision over a church playground means for religious freedom in America
Philly.com: ‘Trinity’ case marks end of originalism.